All Murder, She Baked Movies in Order: Hannah Swensen Mysteries Movies

Started in 2015, the Hannah Swensen/Murder, She Baked aired on the small screen. Adapted from Joanne Fluke’s novels of the same name, the stories give a special twist to the now overpopulated whodunnit genre.

In the story of Murder, She Baked series, we follow Alison Sweeny as she plays the role of a small-town baker who regularly walks into her bakery or other places, only to find a dead body on the floor. As she solves the murder, she has to figure out her romantic feelings towards two of the contenders.

Read: All Mission Impossible Movies

So, if you’re looking to get into this love-ridden murder mystery series, then you’re at the right place. This blog post offers everything you need to know if you want to start watching the franchise in the proper order and answers some of the burning questions about the series.

All Murder, She Baked Movies in Order: Hannah Swensen Mysteries Movies

1. Murder, She Baked: A Chocolate Chip Cookie Mystery

   Streaming On: Amazon Prime Video, fuboTV, Hoopla

   Director: Mark Jean

   Writers: Joanne Fluke and Nancey Silvers

   Stars: Alison Sweeney, Gabriel Hogan, Barbara Niven, Cameron Mathison, Lisa Durupt, Toby Levins, Juliana Wimbles, Susan Hogan, Pauline Egan, Meredith McGeachie, Linda Darlow, Marion Eisman, William Vaughan

   Genres: Crime, Mystery, Romance

   

   The first movie introduces us to the main character and shows us the daily life of Hannah right before the murder takes place.

   Hannah Swensen, a baker, runs the Cookie Jar Bakery, the busiest bakery in Lake Eden. One day, Hannah finds her friend and her delivery driver, Ron, dead behind her bakery. Shook by such a situation, Hannah decides to investigate her own.

   Every time Hannah tries to investigate, she is challenged by the new detective, Mike. As Hannah tries to find the person behind the murders, her mother tries to set her up with the local dentist, Norman. Norman completely supports Hannah in her investigation.

   Through her investigation, Hannah discovers that Ron’s loan shark, Max, might have killed one of his clients after arguing with them. Hannah decides to talk with Max but finds him already dead.

   The movie does a great job of setting up its characters well and engaging the viewers in Hannah’s love story.

2. Murder, She Baked: A Plum Pudding Mystery

   Streaming On: fuboTV, Peacock Premium, DIRECTV, Hallmark Movies

   Director: Kristofer Tabori

   Writers: Joanne Fluke and Nancey Silvers

   Stars: Alison Sweeney, Cameron Mathison, Barbara Niven, Lisa Durupt, Johannah Newmarch, Gabriel Hogan, Ona Grauer, Juliana Wimbles, Kirby Morrow, Farah Fath

   Genres: Crime, Mystery, Romance

   

   A Plum Pudding Mystery continues Hannah’s saga as she again randomly encounters a Dead body in her Bakery and as she warms up to the men trying to woo her.

   Christmas in Edens Lake, Minnesota, is mostly small and quiet, which passes with Hannah usually baking her favorite sweets. Never pursuing romance in her life, Hannah is divided between two men trying to impress her.

   Currently, Hannah has a bigger problem to deal with than romance. Hannah finds Larry Jaeger, owner of a Christmas tree business, dead in her Bakery. Happening for a second time, Hannah has found someone murdered in her Bakery. Hanna can’t help but get involved in the investigation, which rubs Norman and Mike the wrong way.

   At the top of the suspect’s list is Nancy Schmidt, commonly known to be a Radio talk show host, Dr. Love. Nancy is Larry’s ex-wife who claims she had not seen or met Larry in 10 years after he stole all of her money and disappeared.

   As Hannah and Mike investigate further into the case, they discover that Larry had done a lot of bad deeds for which many had wanted him dead. As Hannah gets closer to the truth, she does not realize that the murderer might strike again.

   This movie shows how Hannah has improved at being a detective and helping the authorities. Her feeling towards both men starts growing this problem, giving the movie a funny and warm twist.

3. Murder, She Baked: A Peach Cobbler Mystery

   Streaming On: Hallmark Movies Now Amazon Channel, DIRECTV

   Director: Kristofer Tabori

   Writers: Joanne Fluke, Teena Booth

   Stars: Alison Sweeney, Barbara Niven, Lisa Durupt, Toby Levins, Michelle Harrison, Gabriel Hogan, Juliana Wimbles, Roark Critchlow, Ann Marie Loder, Garry Chalk, Marion Eisman, Clare Filipow

   Genres: Crime, Drama, Mystery, Romance

   

   The third movie in the franchise shows Hannah divided between the two men who like her and trying to make the right decision while investigating the murder of Mike’s friend.

   After evaluating her feelings towards Norman and Mike, Hannah decides to go with Mike. Despite knowing that Norman is more prepared to commit, while Mike has not moved on from his deceased wife Lydia, Hannah wants to go through with Mike.

   Before telling Mike, Hannah notices Mike has invited Melanie Quinn, an old college friend, to live in the town. Hannah starts to think that Mike and Melanie are attracted to each other. Rubbing salt in her wound, Melanie opens a bakery across the street, which steals Hanna’s customers.

   Hannah and Mike’s relationship turns dark when Hannah walks into Melanie’s bakery only to find her dead in the kitchen. Although Mike knows Hannah had no hand in the murder, Mike has to steer clear of her to stay impartial to the investigation as Hannah is the circumstantial suspect and a person with the opportunity and motive.

   As usual, Hannah starts investigating the case. As she can’t meddle with Mike, Hannah turns to Norman, who supports her throughout her problems. This endless support might sway Hannah’s feelings in his favor.

   A Peach Cobbler mystery puts Hannah in the seat as the main suspect in a murder case as she’s trying to figure out her love life and feelings for Mike. Although Hannah completely focuses on Mike, Norman tries to gain her in his way.

4. Murder, She Baked: A Deadly Recipe

   Streaming On: Hallmark Movies Now Amazon Channel, DIRECTV

   Director: Klay Hall

   Writers: Joanne Fluke, Teena Booth, Kraig Wenman

   Stars: Alison Sweeney, Cameron Mathison, Barbara Niven, Lisa Durupt, Toby Levins, Juliana Wimbles, Gabriel Hogan, Aaron Pearl, Lauren K. Robek, Garry Chalk, Jesse Moss

   Genres: Crime, Mystery, Romance

   

   A Deadly Recipe shows how Hannah’s daily life has become very hectic and hard to handle, and when a murder happens, which frames her brother-in-law as the prime suspect, she puts all of her attention to the case.

   Hannah’s brother-in-law, Deputy Bill Todd, decides to run against the harsh and thick lawman Sheriff Grant in a very heated Sheriff election. With her sister ready to let in her pregnancy and a scary encounter with a car thief, Hannah feels like her life is becoming too much for her to handle. Things heat up higher when she discovers the dead body of Sheriff Grant, who seems to be poisoned while holding one of her cupcakes. This makes Bill the prime suspect.

   Determined to prove Bill’s innocence, Hannah starts her investigation and quickly finds out that Grant isn’t well-liked and has a lot of enemies. Hannah’s investigation stirs up many scandals and secrets that Grant was involved in with several suspects.

   Along the way, Hannah finds her supported throughout the investigation by Norman, who is always eager to help her. While collaborating with Mike on the case, she wonders if she is falling for her.

   A Deadly Recipe shows how Hannah has developed throughout the movies and how good a detective she has become. She has slowly started to sort out her romantic feelings towards Mike and how to deal with him better.

5. Murder, She Baked: Just Desserts

   Streaming On: Hallmark Movies Now Amazon Channel

   Director: Kristofer Tabori

   Writers: Joanne Fluke, Melissa Salmons

   Stars: Alison Sweeney, Cameron Mathison, Barbara Niven, Lisa Durupt, Toby Levins, Gabriel Hogan, David Lewis, James Rittinger

   Genres: Crime, Drama, Mystery

   

   Another murder has taken place in Eden Lake, but unlike the norm of Hannah finding the body, the dead body is found by Norman Rhoades, a local dentist.

   The victim is Len Bishop, the school’s basketball team coach, and Norman is a volunteer assistant coach. The body is found right after the airing of Eden Lake Bake-Off, sponsored by Hannah, ends. Len was brought in as a last-minute replacement as the third judge for the semi-finals in the baking contest.

   Mike and the Sheriff’s department start the investigation on the other homicides. Mike, whom Hannah decided to date over Norman, keeps Hannah updated on the case as he knows she can be a significant asset to the case and stop her from starting her investigation.

   The leading suspects include Len’s wife, who had a problem with Len as she suspected he was cheating, Josh Reynolds, a player who couldn’t become a star player, Carl Kimball, the son of a station manager, and the show judges, including Hannah.

   As the investigation moves, incidents threaten Mike and Hannah’s relationship with Norman, who is ready to jump if their relationship cracks.

   As the series progressed, Hannah gained better investigative and detective skills, as shown in this movie. Norman, who has always been a sweet person, has become slightly jealous and starts to portray being a good person on the outside while hiding his true feelings.

6. Sweet Revenge: A Hannah Swensen Mystery

   Streaming On: Hallmark Movies Now Amazon Channel, DIRECTV

   Director: Pat Williams

   Writers: Joanne Fluke, Marcy Holland

   Stars: Markian Tarasiuk, Alison Sweeney, Cameron Mathison, Barbara Niven, Lucia Walters, Juliana Wimbles, Tess Atkins, Reese Alexander, Natasha Burnett

   Genres: Crime, Mystery

   

   Busy with work in her bakery, Hannah has started to go to a 24-hour gym to keep herself healthy. She visits the gym every morning before work. One morning, she comes around a dead body in the gym and contacts Mike to come in and investigate the crime. Mike has been paired with a new partner from the state to keep him under supervision.

   As usual, Hannah can’t help but get involved in the investigation, especially because her baked goods were discovered at the crime scene. By this, she deduces that the murderer had to have been in her shop.

   While Hannah and Mike work on the case in their own way and style, Hannah’s mother, Delores, prepares to debut her new book. This raunchy romance novel tells the adventure of Hannah’s real-life story. Delores is also doing her best to help Hannah prepare for her wedding. With the murder at hand, running the bakery, and a whole wedding to plan, Hannah has a load of work to do.

7. Carrot Cake Murder: A Hannah Swensen Mystery

   Streaming On: fuboTV, DIRECTV

   Director: Pat Williams

   Writer: Melissa Salmons

   Stars: Gabriel Hogan, Barbara Niven, Alison Sweeney, Daylin Willis, Cameron Mathison

   Genres: Crime, Drama, Mystery, Romance

   

   There is trouble in paradise for Hannah Swensen, our main protagonist and amateur investigator, who concludes her latest mystery in Carrot Cake Murder by ending her engagement with her detective fiancé Mike.

   Hannah can see the bigger picture behind the murder, and she can solve the case with her hones detective skills.

   When the Murderer is arrested, Hannah discovers that Mike has been reporting Hannah’s moves to his boss behind her back. Hannah perceives this to mean that Mike is taking advantage of her curiosity about the matter rather than treating her as an equal partner. Unable to endure the condescension, Hannah breaks off the engagement.

   This movie takes a heavily emotional approach to the relationship that Mike and Hannah have developed throughout the previous and how they have a very fragile connection. The movie does not follow any original books, so it has a different tone and direction than the earlier movies.

Conclusion

And those were all the Hannah Swensen/Murder, She Baked in the right watch order. The Hannah Swensen Mystery movies are a cozy bunch you can sit and watch from bed. Since the movies are arranged in linear order, the best way to watch them would be the release order, but most movies can also be watched as standalone.

The mysteries in the movies keep the viewer engaged. At the same time, the romance and comedy aspect of it gives the movies their cozy and comfortable feel. So, suppose you’re looking to get into a fun Whodunnit murder mystery series with a good sprinkle of romance. In that case, the Hannah Swensen mystery movies might be the right pick for you.

Hannah Swensen Mysteries Movies According To IMDb Ratings

• Sweet Revenge: A Hannah Swensen Mystery (2021) – 7.0 By 650 Votes
• Murder, She Baked: A Peach Cobbler Mystery (2016) – 6.8 By 1.4K Votes
• Murder, She Baked: Just Desserts (2017) – 6.8 By 1.2K Votes
• Murder, She Baked: A Plum Pudding Mystery (2015) – 6.7 By 1.5K Votes
• Murder, She Baked: A Deadly Recipe (2016) – 6.7 By 1.3K Votes
• Murder, She Baked: A Chocolate Chip Cookie Mystery (2015) – 6.6 By 2.3K Votes
• Carrot Cake Murder: A Hannah Swensen Mystery (2023) – 6.4 By 155 Votes

FAQs